How to Keep the Peace at Thanksgiving With Your Adult Kids and Grandkids
Picture this. I’ve spent the morning baking a gorgeous pumpkin pie, the crust golden, the whipped cream piled just so, and I hold it up and ask whether you’d like a piece. You politely say, “Yes, Rich, I’d love a piece.” So I walk over and shove the whole thing in your face.
You would never forget that Thanksgiving, though not for the reasons I’d hoped.
Ridiculous, of course. And yet that is precisely what so many of us do with our most precious things. We carry values we have bled for, lessons that cost us decades, and hopes for our children and grandchildren that keep us up at night. Then, when the whole family finally gathers around one table, we serve all of it at once, heaped high, whether anyone asked for seconds or not. I’ll confess I have been guilty of overbaking a time or two myself.
Why Thanksgiving Dinner Turns Into a Family Fight
Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday of the year. It isn’t wrapped in commercialism or buried under a mountain of gifts. It is simply a day to give thanks for this astonishing world we get to live in. Yet for so many families, the very dinner we look forward to all year turns into a kind of nuclear warfare, and we spend the next six months trying to put Humpty Dumpty back together again before we rewind and repeat the whole thing the following November. That matters more than it might seem, because traditions are what steady a family. They help everyone feel safe and anchored. So over the years our family began practicing five simple things, and I have to tell you, it’s remarkable how everything settled down.
1. Welcome Every Family Tradition (and the New In-Laws)
First, let everyone bring their own tradition. Whether you’re hosting or attending, there may be a crazy uncle at the table, a niece with some strong views, or a new in-law who has never seen how your family does things. Before dinner, give everyone a moment to share what they’re grateful for and why, in their own way. We raised our precious daughter and her two brothers with Sherpa and Buddhist roots running deep in their lives, and rather than complicating our holidays, that rich difference has broadened our table and put everyone at ease. Our family looks forward to the little momos our daughter brings every bit as much as the ten-hour Traeger turkey, and they are as much a part of our Thanksgiving as Aunt Mabel’s cranberry recipe. When everyone gets to contribute, no one feels left out.
2. Pass Down One Family Value, Not Five
Second, and perhaps most important, go in with one value. Not five. One. Whoever is leading the gathering, decide ahead of time which single value you hope to plant, and then teach it through a story or an experience rather than a great big blathery lecture. This July my wife and I sat down and re-examined all of our family values. Most of them held solid, but we tightened up one new statement: lions don’t hunt like hyenas. Higher values, higher expectations, and no getting sloppy in how we treat one another. That is the one value we’ll be hitting on this year.
3. Rethink the Kids’ Table: Keep Everyone Eye to Eye
Third, keep everyone eye to eye. There are times a kids’ table makes sense and the kids even want it, but nobody, whatever their age, wants to be looked down on. At our last big family dinner, things got turned on their head. The grandkids took over the big table and kicked every last adult out, and we grown-ups ended up eating our dinner balanced on our laps. Those kids completely reversed the energy in the room. The deepest human need is to be seen and to be heard, and that happens eyeball to eyeball. One of my little grandsons doesn’t speak yet, but when he feels seen, whether I’m pushing a toy car around with him or tossing him a little football, his big bright eyes absolutely light up. He even makes an appearance in the sea chronicles of my upcoming book, Wisdom of a Grandfather, as a little blowfish who puffs right up when he’s noticed. Whether it’s a three-year-old or a sixty-one-year-old who still acts like one, put the eyes at the same level and give everyone an equal voice.
4. How to Handle a Difficult Relative: Set a Start and End Time
Fourth, and this is the one that may ruffle a few turkey feathers (forgive the dad joke, though I’m not terribly sorry), set a start and an end time. If you know a complicated personality is coming, frame the day up front: we’ll gather from 1 until 4. Families get into real trouble when there is no plan and no purpose. Dinner is fine, everyone lingers, someone gets a little ornery, a few naps are taken, a few beers are opened, the football game gets loud, and suddenly there’s a brawl. A clear beginning, a clear ending, and an agenda that keeps things moving help everyone stay on their best behavior.
The Pumpkin Pie Rule for Giving Advice to Adult Children
That’s where the pumpkin pie comes back in, literally and metaphorically. Show them the pie and ask if they’d like a beautiful piece. Then cut the slice deliberately a little smaller than they might want, and present it as though you were serving the king of Persia or the queen of Siam. Let them enjoy it. Let their eyes ask for more. And when they politely ask, “Might I have some more?” you say, “As it happens, I also have a perfectly golden lemon meringue. Which would you prefer?” and serve another small, delicate piece. Whether it’s pie or wisdom, a smaller slice offered with grace carries far more weight and gets you so much further than the whole pie ever could.
5. What to Say When Politics Comes Up at Thanksgiving Dinner
Fifth, always return to gratitude. A wonderful way to begin is to have everyone set their phones on the front desk as they walk in, so the distractions stay at the door. Then anytime there’s even a hint of negativity, gently draw the table back. Can you believe we get to share this beautiful dinner? When someone makes a sharp political comment: Isn’t it unbelievable, the freedoms we have? When someone declares the world is going to hell in a handbasket: Look at this beautiful earth, look at those snow-capped mountains. Gratitude shifts the frequency of an entire room. I’m convinced gratitude is the currency of God, of the divine, whatever you choose to call it, and I’d add that it is the currency of grandparents too. Gratitude is the currency, and small, kind, tender acts are what fuel the machine.
When my wife and I sat down this July to rework our values, it took some honest, roll-up-your-sleeves conversation before we landed on that line about lions and hyenas. If you’d like a head start on finding your one value before the turkey comes out of the oven, I’ve tucked the same simple process we use into a free values guide, and you can work through it in about fifteen minutes.
Keeping the Peace This Thanksgiving
So this Thanksgiving, let’s welcome every tradition to the table, bring one value instead of five, keep every set of eyes at the same level, frame the day with kindness and a clock, and keep circling back to gratitude. And whatever you do, please don’t shove the whole pie in anyone’s face.
I’d love to hear how it goes, along with any wisdom of your own for keeping the peace around the table. Just hit reply and tell me.
Wishing you and yours a peaceful, grateful Thanksgiving,
Rich Christiansen
How To Keep the Peace at Thanksgiving: 5 Tips for Parents and Grandparents: Ep 16 | Calm the Chaos with Rich Christiansen
Does your Thanksgiving dinner end in a family fight, followed by six months of putting Humpty Dumpty back together? Whether you’re a parent or a grandparent, hosting or attending, I share five simple ways to keep the peace at the table, including what happened when the grandkids took over the main table, the one value my wife and I are bringing this year, and why number four may ruffle a few turkey feathers. Watch Here.
Whenever you’re ready, here are some other ways I can help you:
The Free Values Guide – Name the 5 values your grandchildren will inherit, in 15 minutes. A free, fillable guide built on the same process I have used for years with families.
Pattern Breaker Meditations – A free three-part guided experience designed to help you regulate your nervous system, rewire emotional patterns formed early in life, and realign your life with what matters most. Through guided meditations and practical instruction, you can begin addressing repeating patterns at their roots.
Calm the Chaos with Rich Christiansen Podcast– Weekly conversations with thought leaders and everyday people who have faced life’s hardest challenges and found their way through. Real stories, real tools, and frameworks to help you move from chaos into clarity.
Free Tools to help Calm the Chaos – Practical frameworks and tools designed to help you regain clarity, steadiness, and alignment in everyday life.
Legado Family– A framework and community centered on strengthening family systems, legacy, and generational integrity.
